Answer:
The law has now been amended to provide a five-year window for those with market linked pensions to commute the pension in full (refer ‘Complying pension commutations and super reserve changes’ for more information).
Market-linked pensions were usually commenced for one of two reasons. One was to receive a 50 per cent exemption from the amount counting towards the Centrelink/DVA assets test. The other was for Reasonable Benefit Limit (RBL) purposes. Similar to the transfer balance cap rules, the RBL system limited the tax benefits of income streams up to a point.
In return for these benefits were a number of rules that restricted access. For instance, the income received each year was limited to an amount based on the account balance and term remaining. This amount could be varied by +/-10 per cent. Lump sum payments are not available. If the pension was commuted in full, the proceeds needed to be rolled over to a similarly restrictive income stream.
There are many reasons why someone may want to close their market-linked pension, these include:
- They are no longer receiving a Centrelink/Department of Veterans’ Affairs (DVA) benefit from the pension
- They commenced the pension for RBL purposes, which were abolished in 2007
- Their income needs are not being met and they require greater accessibility
- They want to withdraw the benefit from the super environment for estate planning purposes
When looking at commuting there are a number of areas to consider, including:
Centrelink/DVA
Many individuals will be receiving a 50 per cent assets test exemption, which may increase their Centrelink/DVA entitlement. For Centrelink purposes, this could equate to an increased Age Pension of up to 3.9 per cent of the balance of the pension.
In addition to the assets test considerations, the income test should also be considered. Market-linked pensions are assessed on the income received less a deduction amount (ie the purchase price less commutations divided by the term at commencement). This is very different to the deeming that would apply if the funds were held in financial investments, such as super (accumulation and/or account-based pensions) or cash, shares, managed funds in the individual’s name.
Longer term planning is also worth considering. At the moment, the market-linked pension may not be providing a Centrelink/DVA benefit however if there is a reversionary nomination in place and the client dies, retaining the pension may provide a Centrelink/DVA benefit for the reversionary beneficiary.
Under current law, where a market-linked pension is commuted and not used to commence a similar income stream, the Government will retrospectively treat the market-linked pension as not having the partial or full assets test exemption from commencement. The Government can then clawback five years’ worth of overpayments from Centrelink/DVA. On the 14th of December 2024, the Government issued a press release indicating that the clawback won’t apply. It is expected that the Government will issue a legislative instrument to waive this debt.
Commonwealth Senior Health Card (CSHC)
Market-linked pensions aren’t included in the CSHC’s income test.
If commuted and moved to an asset that will have income counting to the CSHC’s test, how will this impact their eligibility. Investments that create assessable income for the individual and account-based pensions will result in additional income counting towards the CSHC’s test.
Possible negative transfer balance cap (TBC) implications
For market-linked pensions in place prior to 1 July 2017, the commutation debit will be equal to the original credit less the sum of:
- Pension payments received from 1 July 2017 to 30 June of the financial year prior to commutation
- The greater of the minimum pension payment required for the financial year of commutation, and the actual pension payment received in that year
- Any prior debits (excluding family law payment splits)
The debit value will usually be different to the proceeds received from the commutation. Where the proceeds are greater and the intention is to commence another income stream (eg account-based pension), the individual will use more of their TBC, potentially limiting the amount of the proceeds they use for the new pension, which could reduce the tax effectiveness of their financial plan.
If the market linked pension commenced on or after 1 July 2017 (eg rolled over from another complying income stream), the TBC debit will be equal to the value of the pension at the time of commutation.
Tax
Market-linked pensions are usually very tax effective due to the exemption from tax in the super fund. In addition, pension payments for those 60 and over are tax free.
The tax position of the alternatives varies significantly and can be dependent on the individual’s circumstances. For those with little to no income, investing in their own name may be tax effective but won’t be for those with higher incomes. For those that can move to an account-based pension (without exceeding the TBC), the current tax effectiveness will be retained.
Estate planning
A change to the client’s estate plan may be required where the market-linked pension occurs. Factors such as the time, effort and cost should be considered.
Many individuals who have market-linked pensions will be quite old and may not have the capacity to amend the estate plan. For instance, those that are under a legal disability will be unable to alter their will.
Pension flexibility and access to capital
One of the main limitations of market-linked pensions is the restriction around the level of income that can be received. In addition, there’s very limited ability to access the capital, so much so that the super laws don’t allow access even in the case of severe financial hardship.
Options such as an account-based pension have far fewer restrictions. The annual pension payment is only limited by a minimum amount, not an upper amount. It’s easier to determine each year and reduces the regulatory risks, particularly for SMSFs. There’s also access to capital by way of lump sum payments.
Keep in mind that when commuting the pension, the pro-rata pension for the year must be paid before the commutation takes place. For large super funds, this will be managed by the fund however can be easily overlooked for self-managed super funds (SMSFs).
Product modernisation
The market-linked products were created a long time ago and may not have been updated as product features have advanced. Moving into a more modern product may be in the clients’ interest.